I think this overview question asking "What is an overview of the main arguments that angels do or do not already exist at Genesis 1:1" is fine although it is not explicitly asking an overview of denominational positions.
Example from outside SE
By adding enough details to the question we can expect an answer to contain no more than 5 views. We have literally dozens of this type of questions answered in book format such as Zondervan's 38 volume Counterpoints Library and IVP Academic's 22 volume Spectrum Multiview Book Series. The views in these books are not always cleanly divided among denominational lines either.
How is it different than questions about denominational positions?
It's different since
"main arguments" don't depend on authority speaking for a denomination, or a theologian speaking on behalf of a theological tradition.
"main arguments" implies an emphasis on the argument itself: an informed theological speculation not necessarily backed by authority, but prominent enough in circulation. Things like "concentric cessationism", "inclusivism", "sacraments as means of grace", etc.
the boundary separating the arguments is based on criteria intrinsic in the argument itself, not on sociological factor of who's accepting which argument
the sociological boundary of the arguments can cross denominational boundary, either spanning (like charismatic movement) or splitting (like baptism within the Reformed tradition)
Previous discussion on Overview questions
This meta question can then supplement Caleb's answer on "How should I ask overview questions: on one matter from all of the Christian spectrum?" as Question type ④ :
- What are the main Christian arguments about X?
The discussion question
My meta question is then:
What is the official policy of asking this type of overview question?
How should the question be tagged? Do we reuse
comparative-christianityand update the tag definition from
"comparisons of two or more denominations"
"comparisons of two or more theological positions / denominations"
or do we create another tag for overview question type ④?