What if someone else sins for you is put on hold (rightly so) for being a truth question of the form "Is X a sin?".

I think this question is interesting and could be salvaged if it is reformulated as "Are there examples from the Bible where behavior X is punished?" which seems to avoid the Truth issue and is just a question for an example from the text. That seems answerable. If there are no examples it still does not mean X is a sin, nor does a punishment necessarily mean X is a sin today. But for some issues it points in a certain direction.

So... can and should this question, or others like it, be salvaged in this way? Or is too close to the unwanted "Is X a sin?"?

  • 1
    What you're proposing is what we call a verse search question, and would also be off-topic. Because what constitutes a valid example is very much a matter of personal interpretation. – curiousdannii Sep 12 '19 at 13:44
  • @curiousdannii Hmm okay additionally it would be not really possible to answer as "No, there are no examples", right? – kutschkem Sep 12 '19 at 13:46
  • Maybe for some questions, but I think the majority would have some grey areas. The whole category is risky, and a question would have to make its case well that it can be answered objectively. – curiousdannii Sep 12 '19 at 13:49
  • Can someone kill another person for you? I think not. Leave it closed. It would be extremely hard to make this question on topic. – Ken Graham Sep 14 '19 at 13:24

I think you could ask from a Natural Law perspective, but this question makes a doctrinal assumption that says every sin is enumerated in the Bible. If there was such a group, which is doubtful. I don't think there's any way to answer the question objectively, it is off topic on at least 3 levels.

  • is X a sin
  • where is it in the Bible
  • not scoped

What one could ask (on another site, perhaps), is why did God want to kill Balaam rather than Balak?

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .