7

I mean, in particular, this answer: https://christianity.stackexchange.com/a/59972/25763

My first instinct was to flag it, however, seeing that already 2 ppl have downvoted it before me w/o flaggint it I started wondering if flagging this answer was appropriate.

The answer consists almost solely of a link to a YT video whose purpose seems to be the propagation of a particular sect, as well as attacking Catholicism. I haven't watched the whole video (it's almost 20mins long); so I'm not sure if this video touches the subject of the question; but even if it does it is clear that the primary purpose of this answer is the propagation of the answerer's particular sect.

Is such an answer on-topic here? Is it appropriate for me to flag such answers?

||||||
  • 1
    FLAG FLAG FLAG. yes, flag it. Total spam. A waste of our time. If enough flags come in on a single post or comment, auto-scripts will remove it, rather than a moderator having to take the time to handle it. This would be "community action", a desired and even preferred thing. – 3961 Sep 23 '17 at 0:14
8

Yep, that answer is (well, was) definitely deserving of flags. Such an "answer" doesn't work well for this site for a number of reasons, such as:

  • It doesn't provide the Catholic view of the legality of non-Catholic religions, and thus is "not an answer"
  • It basically consists of a link to an external site, which we strongly discourage – while references are encouraged, it's essential that answers here stand on their own
  • It's quite "spammy" – given that it's just a link, and an irrelevant link at that

So yes, this should have been flagged as either Not An Answer, or Very Low Quality, or Spam. And don't worry – it was indeed flagged almost immediately by one of our other users. Those flags are only visible to moderators, not regular users, but they start the process of eliminating such content.

I hope in the future you'll feel free to flag things like this. If you're not sure, it's fine to flag anyway; you might get a "declined" flag or two, but we appreciate your efforts in cleaning up the site. Thanks!

||||||

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .