I would like to know whether there are any scholars, or philosophers, or doctrines -- or really, anyone at all -- in any sect or denomination of Christianity, who address the question, "Why does God allow millions of people who earnestly seek him to be so wrong that they would go to Hell?" (I'm thinking of the not-uncommon Christian view of Muslims, for example.) I tried asking this question a few days ago on C.SE, and got quite a black eye over it. Almost immediately, two people voted to close the question. One of them said it was too broad, in that I was asking two questions: does anyone address... and why would God allow... Another said that my question doesn't fall under the C.SE question guidelines, and also that I should explain why I believe that millions of people will go to Hell. When I pointed out that it wasn't my belief, but the belief of countless Christian sects, he said that countless Christian sects is too broad.
I'm confused by both of these responses. First, I'm not asking the why would God allow... question. I thought that was clear? Maybe not. Second, I realize that my question doesn't precisely match any of the enumerated types of questions listed here and here, but I should hope that that wouldn't be a reason for closing a question. Yes, a potential warning flag, but I would have thought that a more specific explanation could be given as to why the question is inappropriate.
As for explaining why I believe, or somehow qualifying my question to ask about one particular denomination's belief that there is a Hell where people will actually go, I am utterly baffled. I'm not asking about why people go to Hell, or why a particular denomination believes it. I'm trying to ask whether anyone addresses this "Why would God..." kind of question with respect to the widely held (although admittedly not universal) belief that many people will be judged and condemned, whether to an ECT Hell or just destruction, that is, punishment, or a default "separation from God" experience.
For fear of having it forcibly deleted and/or losing reputation points, I deleted the question. (I try not to get too fixated on reputation points, but I can take only so much of the humiliation I feel when the community disapproves of my posts. I realize that some people might not understand the feelings I experience -- even I don't always understand my feelings -- but they happen anyway.)
Is my question entirely inappropriate for C.SE? If so, could someone please help me to understand why, beyond the simple fact that it doesn't match the broad guidelines I've linked to above? That is, if you can see the source of my confusion, of course. Otherwise, ok, I will accept that the community finds my question entirely inappropriate.
If it's an ok question, could someone please help me to formulate it such that it won't get close votes?