6

This was asked (and now closed) earlier:

Is it possible for an atheist to be moral?

I really had to close this question down to keep the precepts of your own FAQ even remotely defensible.

The wording is roughly:

We are here to talk about Christianity … Users do not expect to be challenged on their belief system, and questions asked under false pretense just to "make a point" or to challenge those tenets will be closed as Not Constructive.

This community cannot stand under the umbrella of such protection and use it to strike out at other belief systems. It doesn't matter that you're looking for the "Christian view" on Atheism, or Judaism or any other religion. If I tell your brother that he is not allow to hit you, that doesn't mean it's okay to strike at him with impunity.

This community is going to fight long and hard to keep non-Christians from using this platform to constantly challenge and taunt you about your belief system. When it comes down to it, if the question is NOT about Christianity, it should be off topic.

  • 2
    You're absolutely correct and I completely agree! From this stance, we also need to stop questions regarding comparisons to all other religions. This site isn't well suited for such discussions. (I'm glad we have beta to be able to hammer out some of these details.) – Richard Sep 21 '11 at 0:55
  • We need to address these few as well: islam – Richard Sep 21 '11 at 0:57
  • 1
    @Richard: I disagree on the comparative thing being a problem. I don't think that is at all the same problem that Robert is worried about here. There are many cases where the best way to define something is to examine what it is not. I will try to work up an argument/discussion on this issue in a few days, but I would request no action without some review on this first. – Caleb Sep 21 '11 at 7:52
  • 1
    @Richard I agree with Caleb. My intention was NOT to elicit an all-out moratorium on mentioning other religions. My concern was using those questions to pass judgment, dump on, or even question the legitimacy of other cultures. We ask folks not to use Christianity SE to challenge your belief system. That courtesy will have to work both ways. So when someone asks various shades of "Is <other group> moral/wrong about/hated by God/damned to hell/the cause of world problems/etc.", I would simply say that it's off topic for this site. – Robert Cartaino Sep 21 '11 at 19:14
6

I agree with user unknown's comment on the original question:

How is the question a question about Christianity? Are you asking about a canonical answer between Christians, how they think about it? Is this a scientific question about human behaviour and sociology, religious preferences and moral acting, or is it a question how to read the bible, to come to an answer in Christian faith? Or do you expect both answers to match?

This question would have to be substantially rewritten before it would be a good fit for this site.

2

Here's how I'd edit it:

Is morality possible apart from God?

Can an individual live in accord with Christian morality, exemplified by the commandment to love others as Jesus loves you, but be totally ignorant of the Gospel?

What distinctions could be made between someone ignorant of the Gospel and someone whose reason has led them to reject Christ?


Any problem with that?

  • 2
    I wouldn't think this is off-topic, but I'm not sure it's a very good question either. It should be very obvious that morality is possible apart from God, for anyone that knows a notable amount of atheists IRL. If this was turned into something more specific, I'd be happier with it (e.g. what does the Bible/Catholic Catechism say about this). – dancek Sep 21 '11 at 22:30
  • @dancek, I agree, I just thought that would change the intent of the question (and invalidate all existing answers) too much. – Peter Turner Sep 22 '11 at 13:02
  • You're probably right. I'd say it's time for a new question then. – dancek Sep 22 '11 at 13:04

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .