So, I'm looking at my badges, and my first thought is, "I have more than 59!"
Looking at the Nice Answer, that's 67 right there :) Is this just a CSS issue, or is there an actual calculation error going on?
You see, you have 59 distinct badges, even though a few of them have been awarded multiple times.
Even Jon Skeet's page has "only" 587 badges, even though he has more than 2k(!) Enlightened badges.
So, it's by design.