I noticed a question on the main board that currently has a cumulative vote score of -2, as well as some votes to close.
I'm new to Christianity.SE (and to SE generally), and I'm trying to develop a better understanding of just what is and is not on-topic at C.SE. There seem to be a lot of different guidelines, some of which are clearly explained in the faq, and others that, as far as I can tell, aren't.
- Do the moderators & other high reputation users on C.SE agree with the overall score of -2 on the linked question?
- Is that score more appropriate for the question as it was written before it was sharpened by Caleb's edits?
- I think I can understand how the "more generally" portion in the question would be inappropriate for the SE format; is that the only remaining problematic aspect? Or, is that not problematic at all?