Skip to main content
Christianity

Return to Question

Tweeted twitter.com/StackChristian/status/877942043724713985
added 53 characters in body
Source Link
bruised reed
bruised reed
  • 12.6k
  • 12
  • 18

This situation is very fishy:

Catholic restricted from Communion has been closed as a duplicate of Catholic baptized in another church which itself has been closed as an unclear question.

It's true that the OP has had two goes at asking the same question. The second iteration is far more clear and is certainly clear enough now for it wasn'tnot to be closed for that reason. In what world does it make sense to close this one as a duplicate of the first one rather than the other way around?

I personally would think that we should never have duplicate pointers to unclear questions - what say you all?

This situation is very fishy:

Catholic restricted from Communion has been closed as a duplicate of Catholic baptized in another church which itself has been closed as an unclear question.

It's true that the OP has had two goes at asking the same question. The second iteration is far more clear and it wasn't closed. In what world does it make sense to close this one as a duplicate of the first one rather than the other way around?

I personally would think that we should never have duplicate pointers to unclear questions - what say you all?

This situation is very fishy:

Catholic restricted from Communion has been closed as a duplicate of Catholic baptized in another church which itself has been closed as an unclear question.

It's true that the OP has had two goes at asking the same question. The second iteration is far more clear and is certainly clear enough now for it not to be closed for that reason. In what world does it make sense to close this one as a duplicate of the first one rather than the other way around?

I personally would think that we should never have duplicate pointers to unclear questions - what say you all?

Source Link
bruised reed
bruised reed
  • 12.6k
  • 12
  • 18

How can we have a duplicate of an unclear question?

This situation is very fishy:

Catholic restricted from Communion has been closed as a duplicate of Catholic baptized in another church which itself has been closed as an unclear question.

It's true that the OP has had two goes at asking the same question. The second iteration is far more clear and it wasn't closed. In what world does it make sense to close this one as a duplicate of the first one rather than the other way around?

I personally would think that we should never have duplicate pointers to unclear questions - what say you all?