Skip to main content
Christianity

Return to Answer

replaced http://christianity.stackexchange.com/ with https://christianity.stackexchange.com/
Source Link
Community Bot
Community Bot
  • 1

Would it be helpful to have a custom message for Truth questions needing a denominational specification? As it is currently, these questions tend to be closed as not constructive, and when one is left open (1,1, and maybe 22), the question is never improved because it gets votes and [a variety of] answers.

Something like (quoting fredsbend in a comment in #2 above):

As worded, this is what the community here might call a Truth question. You are obviously looking for an answer to what you should do according to what is true and right. Conversely, questions on this site should be scoped within a particular doctrine or denomination.

Would it be helpful to have a custom message for Truth questions needing a denominational specification? As it is currently, these questions tend to be closed as not constructive, and when one is left open (1, and maybe 2), the question is never improved because it gets votes and [a variety of] answers.

Something like (quoting fredsbend in a comment in #2 above):

As worded, this is what the community here might call a Truth question. You are obviously looking for an answer to what you should do according to what is true and right. Conversely, questions on this site should be scoped within a particular doctrine or denomination.

Would it be helpful to have a custom message for Truth questions needing a denominational specification? As it is currently, these questions tend to be closed as not constructive, and when one is left open (1, and maybe 2), the question is never improved because it gets votes and [a variety of] answers.

Something like (quoting fredsbend in a comment in #2 above):

As worded, this is what the community here might call a Truth question. You are obviously looking for an answer to what you should do according to what is true and right. Conversely, questions on this site should be scoped within a particular doctrine or denomination.

Source Link
Ryan Frame
Ryan Frame
  • 2.6k
  • 12
  • 9

Would it be helpful to have a custom message for Truth questions needing a denominational specification? As it is currently, these questions tend to be closed as not constructive, and when one is left open (1, and maybe 2), the question is never improved because it gets votes and [a variety of] answers.

Something like (quoting fredsbend in a comment in #2 above):

As worded, this is what the community here might call a Truth question. You are obviously looking for an answer to what you should do according to what is true and right. Conversely, questions on this site should be scoped within a particular doctrine or denomination.